Andes mints
York peppermint patties
Raisinets (specifically dark chocolate ones)
Midnight Milky Ways
Twix
Watermelon Sour Patch Kids
Sour and regular gummy worms
Skittles (preferably blue or purple)
Starburst
Twizzlers
Smarties
Hershey's cookies & cream bars
Laffy Taffy (strawberry & banana)
Any kind of dark chocolate
Jelly Belly candy